The Hottest Christmas Toy Every Year of the 1990s

The hottest Christmas toys of the 1990s, year by year—from Ninja Turtles and Super Nintendo to Elmo, Furby and Pokémon, with context behind each pick.

The hottest Christmas toy from every year of the 1990s featuring popular 90s toys like Super Nintendo, Tickle Me Elmo, Furby and Pokémon

Finding the right Christmas toy in the 1990s could mean calling three stores, driving to a fourth, and coming home with nothing. The child asking for it usually saw the television commercial. The parent saw the empty shelf.

The toys themselves were an odd assortment: a $200 game console, a cassette recorder from a movie, a purple dinosaur, and a pocket-sized pet that needed feeding during the school day. Some appealed to preschoolers; others absorbed the attention of older children and, eventually, adult collectors. Treating them all as the same kind of craze misses much of what made the decade interesting.

These are our U.S. editorial picks for the Christmas toys that defined 1990–1999, drawing on holiday reporting, cultural reach, and the difficulty of finding them. The list is not a definitive annual sales ranking. Some picks, especially Beanie Babies and Tamagotchi, reflect a collecting or play craze that extended beyond the holiday season.

Infographic showing the hottest Christmas toy for every year from 1990 through 1999

The Hottest Christmas Toy of Every Year in the '90s

Year Our Pick
1990 Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
1991 Super Nintendo Entertainment System
1992 Barney
1993 Deluxe Talkboy
1994 Mighty Morphin Power Rangers
1995 Beanie Babies
1996 Tickle Me Elmo
1997 Tamagotchi
1998 Furby
1999 Pokémon

1990: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

Original Playmates Ninja Turtle action figures and Party Wagon beside Christmas presents

Buying one Ninja Turtle left plenty of room for the next Christmas list. Leonardo needed the other three Turtles. They needed someone to fight, and somewhere to drive. Playmates supplied Shredder, Bebop, Rocksteady, the Party Wagon, and the Technodrome, giving children an expanding cast to collect rather than a purchase they could consider finished.

The cartoon had already made the characters familiar, and the first live-action movie arrived in 1990. For a child following both, the toy aisle offered a way to keep the story going after the television was switched off. The figures were colorful, distinct, and easy to turn into a battle on the bedroom floor.

A November 1990 Los Angeles Times report identified the Turtles as the nation's hottest-selling toy characters. That is strong support for this year's selection.

The line also gave relatives options at different prices. One person could buy a figure; another could take on the larger playset. A child's collection might grow across several wrapped boxes, with each gift supplying another piece of the same world.

1991: Super Nintendo Entertainment System

North American Super Nintendo with Super Mario World and a CRT television at Christmas

At around $200, a Super Nintendo was a substantial Christmas request. A family that already owned an NES—one of the big Christmas toys of the 1980s—had to decide whether to buy another console, while a child watching the new games could have a much simpler view of the matter.

Nintendo's new system reached American stores shortly before the holiday season, as Sega's Genesis was already competing for attention. The appeal was visible on the screen: richer color, larger characters, and games that made the familiar NES look older than it had a few months earlier.

Contemporary coverage put the Super Nintendo at $199, with games costing extra. The expense helps explain why it belongs here as a coveted big gift, even though plenty of families were buying dolls, board games, and other less expensive presents.

Super Mario World, included with the launch package, gave the box an immediate purpose. Once the system was connected to the television, there was a whole new Mario game to explore. For households moving up from the NES, that first session with Yoshi was a persuasive demonstration of what the purchase had bought.

Remember the hardware as well as the games? Try our Nintendo systems quiz.

1992: Barney

Early Barney plush dinosaur beside an opened Christmas present

Barney makes more sense on this list when you remember who was asking for him. The audience was preschoolers, many of whom wanted a soft version of the dinosaur they watched singing on PBS. A plush Barney could sit beside them while the television Barney led the songs.

Barney & Friends made its national PBS debut in April 1992. By December, the merchandise was selling briskly. An Associated Press report published that month said JCPenney expected to sell one million Barney dolls that year, mostly during the holidays. That was a retailer's forecast, rather than a final nationwide sales total, but it shows the scale of the demand.

This was also a crowded toy year. The Playthings survey put Troll dolls first in its 1992 bestseller list. Totally Hair Barbie and other familiar lines had their own claim on children's wish lists.

Our choice is Barney because of the speed of his arrival in preschool households. It should not be read as a claim that he outsold every toy in America. An older sibling might have found the dinosaur irritating; the younger child asking for him had a very different relationship with the show.

1993: Talkboy

Tiger Electronics Deluxe Talkboy cassette recorder with extended microphone

Kevin McCallister made the Talkboy look useful in ways a normal cassette recorder never had. In Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, changing the speed of a recorded voice helped him impersonate an adult. Children could see the possibilities without needing much of a sales pitch.

The chronology matters. A retail Talkboy was sold in 1992, alongside the film; it was not created only after children demanded one. The Deluxe version followed in 1993. Vanity Fair's interviews with people involved in the launch trace the shortage to renewed demand after the movie's home-video release, when retailers had ordered too few recorders.

The Deluxe Talkboy's voice-changing feature was tangible and easy to experiment with. Its operating instructions explain how changing recording and playback speeds could deepen a voice or raise its pitch. A few words on tape were enough to test it, then try again with a different voice or line from the movie.

Power Rangers were also gathering momentum that Christmas. Talkboy gets our 1993 spot because the appeal was so closely tied to a particular movie and a particular piece of technology: children could hold a working version of Kevin's gadget, complete with a cassette to rewind.

1994: Mighty Morphin Power Rangers

Five original Mighty Morphin Power Rangers action figures on a carpet at Christmas

Power Rangers gave parents a shopping problem with several possible answers. Was the request for an individual Ranger, a Morpher, a weapon, or a Megazord? The name on the list could cover a modest action figure or a much larger present.

The series had debuted in America in 1993, bringing together costumed heroes, martial arts, monsters, and enormous robots. By Christmas 1994, the merchandising had spread well beyond a handful of figures. Children could choose a favorite Ranger and then ask for the equipment and robots associated with the show.

Toys “R” Us listed all Power Ranger products among its hot items for Christmas 1994. The breadth of that recommendation is telling: the retailer was selling an entire television franchise.

A Megazord offered something the smaller figures could not—the chance to act out the show's giant-robot battles at a different scale. The variety helped the line remain relevant across more than one Christmas, although it also meant that finding a Power Rangers box was only part of the job. It still had to be the one the child wanted.

1995: Beanie Babies

Early Ty Beanie Babies Spot, Chocolate, Squealer and Patti with heart tags

Beanie Babies were attracting collectors in the mid-1990s, before the nationwide frenzy most people remember. Our 1995 pick marks an early stage of that collecting story.

Ty Warner's small, bean-filled animals had an advantage over the expensive electronics elsewhere in the toy aisle: buying another animal was a relatively modest request. The designs were different enough to collect, and the retirement of particular animals gave shoppers a reason to look beyond whichever one happened to be on the shelf.

Contemporary 1995 reporting favored Barbie and other established toys. We are retaining Beanie Babies as our pick for an emerging collecting craze, not presenting them as a verified national Christmas sales champion.

The price guides, inflated resale values, and dreams of funding a college education belong to the later boom. In this earlier chapter, the appeal was simpler: a small stuffed animal could become the start of a collection.

1996: Tickle Me Elmo

Original Tyco Tickle Me Elmo plush beside its green-and-white retail box

A toy that laughed and shook when tickled became a much larger problem for adults trying to buy it. Tickle Me Elmo normally cost around $30. Once stock became scarce, resale prices could run into hundreds of dollars, turning an affordable present into a choice between paying too much and continuing the search.

The toy's demonstration was brief and effective. Press the red Sesame Street character, hear the laughter, watch it shake. Television exposure could communicate the appeal in seconds; stores then had to deal with the requests it generated.

A December 1996 CNN report captured both the excitement and the limits of calling any one toy a universal winner. FAO Schwarz's chief described the media-fueled demand while noting that other stuffed animals and classic toys were also selling well. Elmo's notoriety did not mean every child wanted one.

Older children might have been hoping for a Nintendo 64 instead. Yet Elmo became the holiday's shopping story because the ordinary retail transaction had broken down. Having enough money for the advertised price no longer guaranteed that a parent could bring the toy home.

1997: Tamagotchi

Translucent blue Tamagotchi with yellow buttons resting in a child’s palm

A Tamagotchi could make demands at inconvenient times. The tiny creature on its screen needed food, play, and care, whether its owner was at home or sitting in class. Leaving it alone for too long risked an unhappy outcome, so putting the toy away was not as straightforward as dropping an action figure into a box.

The egg-shaped device was small enough to carry almost anywhere. Three buttons provided the means to look after a pet whose needs were represented by a few pixels. Its simplicity helped make the responsibility legible: a child could see what needed doing and worry about what would happen if it went undone.

The classroom conflict was real. Reporting from June 1997 described teachers frustrated by pupils tending virtual pets during lessons. The owner saw a creature needing attention; the teacher saw another interruption.

Our 1997 pick reflects the wider virtual-pet craze documented earlier that year. Tamagotchi could fit into a pocket or a Christmas stocking, but caring for it took more time than its size suggested.

1998: Furby

Two original-generation Furby electronic toys on a coffee table

Furby was a peculiar combination of soft toy and moving machine. It blinked, moved its mouth, and responded to being handled. Its Furbish speech gradually gave way to more English, encouraging the impression that the owner was raising a creature with its own developing personality.

The original toy used preprogrammed words and responses. Wired's October 1998 launch coverage explained the electronics behind the performance, including sensors and a vocabulary already built into the toy. Much of the charm came from watching those responses in a furry body rather than on a screen.

Finding one became the harder part of the experience. The Washington Post was covering the Furby craze in November. As with Elmo, the relatively approachable retail price did little good when a store had none left.

There was a change in the search, too. By the end of the decade, shoppers could look online as well as call stores or drive between them. The internet gave them another place to hunt, although finding a listing did not necessarily mean finding a Furby at its normal price.

1999: Pokémon

Pokémon card binder, original Game Boy and Pokémon Red cartridge during a card trade

A request for Pokémon required a follow-up question. Cards? A Game Boy game? A Pikachu plush? By Christmas 1999, the same name appeared across enough products that buying something with the right logo could still produce the wrong gift.

The games supplied creatures to catch and trade; the television series made them recognizable beyond the Game Boy screen. Trading cards added a different kind of collecting. Another pack might contain something missing from a child's collection, and duplicates could become part of a trade with a friend.

A November 1999 Los Angeles Times report identified Pokémon cards and games as that season's hottest toys. The emphasis on both helps explain why Pokémon is represented here as a franchise rather than a single item.

Parents had to learn distinctions their children already understood. A pack of cards and a video game were different purchases, even when both featured the same characters. Pokémon's reach made the brand easy to recognize; choosing the particular present still took some attention to the wish list.

The Christmas Toy Craze Was Different Before Online Shopping

Much of the 1990s toy hunt depended on information that was difficult to get. Parents checked newspaper advertisements, called Toys “R” Us and other retailers, and asked employees when another shipment might arrive. A drive to the next shopping center could end at another empty shelf.

Online shopping was becoming an option by the late 1990s, so it would be misleading to describe the whole decade as entirely offline. For many households, though, the search still meant telephone calls and store visits. The time spent looking could become as memorable as the money spent buying.

That is the part a child opening the box might never have seen. The toy arrived without an account of the unsuccessful trips that came before it. Years later, parent and child could remember the same Christmas for quite different reasons.

Which toy was on your Christmas list—and if you were the person shopping for it, how hard was it to find?

For another trip through the decade, test your 1990s knowledge with our 50-question quiz.